Jun 2, 2023

The Hidden Costs of Multiple Contingency Recruitment Agencies: A Call to Employers

Unmasking the hidden pitfalls of using multiple contingency recruiters. Discover why this approach could compromise your hiring quality and delay your vacancy filling.

The Hidden Costs of Multiple Contingency Recruitment Agencies: A Call to Employers

In the complex world of hiring, employers often turn to contingency recruitment agencies to fill their vacancies. However, it's important to evaluate the potential pitfalls of partnering with multiple such agencies. Here are the reasons you might want to reconsider this approach.

  1. Fee Dictates Focus: Contingency recruiters earn their fees once a role is filled, meaning they naturally gravitate towards clients who pay the highest fees. Your vacancies might not get the attention they deserve if other clients are offering a larger reward.
  2. Direct Competition: Multiple recruitment agencies inevitably put your vacancies in direct competition with other clients. The competition for your recruiter's time and resources might delay the filling of your position and decrease the quality of the candidates you receive.
  3. Brand Biases: Agencies often favour popular brands, as they’re more likely to attract high-quality candidates quickly. If your brand doesn’t have the same level of recognition, your roles may receive less attention.
  4. Motivation Mismatch: With contingency recruitment, there's a risk that the agency won't be fully committed to your search. After all, they’re only paid if they fill the role. With multiple clients on their books, there's always a chance they'll deprioritize your vacancies.
  5. Questionable Candidate Quality: Due to the competitive nature of contingency recruitment, there's a pressure to present candidates quickly. This urgency might result in agencies pushing candidates who are not entirely suitable for your roles just to increase their chances of filling the position.

By all means, contingency recruiters can offer value, but engaging multiple agencies may dilute the attention your vacancies receive and compromise the quality of candidates. Instead, consider building relationships with select agencies who understand your industry, company culture, and hiring needs. Or better yet, invest in enhancing your direct hiring strategies.

Remember, successful recruitment isn't just about filling a vacancy—it's about finding the perfect match for your company to foster growth and success. The quality of your hires will always trump the quantity of CVs received, so it's crucial to consider the real impact of your recruitment strategy.

Become the manager that finds hiring easy!